When Democracy Loses Its Civilty: A Defence Of Democracy, Human Dignity and The Rule Of Law
By Olukayode Ajulo, Member, Chatham House – The Royal Institute of International Affairs, London
An appeal to Chatham House and the British authorities following the reported confrontation involving Nigeria’s INEC Chairman in London
There are moments when an incident, seemingly confined to a particular place and involving particular individuals, speaks to something much larger than itself. The reported confrontation involving the Chairman of Nigeria’s Independent National Electoral Commission (INEC), Professor Joash Amupitan, outside Chatham House in London on 12 November 2026, is one such moment.
I have followed the reports with considerable concern. Not simply because the person involved is the head of an important Nigerian constitutional institution, but because of what the incident represents for the values that ought to govern democratic societies: civility, restraint, human dignity and respect for the rule of law.
As a member of Chatham House, I feel a particular responsibility to express my concern. Chatham House is more than a distinguished London institution. It is part of Britain’s enduring contribution to international intellectual life, a place where difficult questions are confronted, opposing views are entertained and public institutions are subjected to scrutiny through reasoned debate.
It would be a profound contradiction if an institution devoted to dialogue and the peaceful exchange of ideas were to become associated with an atmosphere in which disagreement spills over into intimidation.
Let me state unequivocally that I have the utmost respect for citizens’ right to protest. For nearly 40 years, promoting and defending this fundamental freedom has been central to my life, for it remains one of democracy’s most vital pillars.
Public officials must be questioned, institutions must be scrutinised and those entrusted with public responsibilities must never mistake public office for immunity from criticism.
Indeed, INEC has an enormous responsibility to the Nigerian people. Its independence, transparency and credibility are essential to the legitimacy of our electoral democracy. Any genuine concerns about the voters’ register, the integrity of electoral processes or the Commission’s preparedness for future elections deserve answers. Such concerns should not be dismissed, trivialised or treated as acts of disloyalty.
But there is a line that a civilised society must never lose sight of: the line between protest and intimidation.
The freedom to express dissatisfaction cannot become the freedom to threaten another person’s dignity or security. The right to assemble cannot become a licence to obstruct, harass or endanger others. And the legitimate demand for accountability cannot be transformed into a public spectacle of personal humiliation.
Democracy must protect the voice of the protester, but it must equally protect the person against whom the protest is directed.
What history ought to have taught us
Perhaps the best way to understand the danger before us is to look backwards.
Medieval Europe, for all its remarkable intellectual, architectural and spiritual achievements, also witnessed periods in which fear, prejudice, religious intolerance and collective passions overwhelmed reason. There were times when accusation became conviction, when the strength of a crowd substituted for the authority of law, and when individuals were deprived of dignity simply because they stood on the wrong side of popular sentiment.
The lesson of that age is not that people should abandon their convictions. It is that conviction without restraint can become destructive.
The Renaissance brought a different intellectual spirit. It rekindled an appreciation of human dignity, reason, inquiry and the capacity of the individual to think freely. The works of Erasmus, Thomas More and other humanist thinkers helped shape a tradition in which the human person, rather than the unchecked authority of the crowd, occupied a central place in moral and intellectual reflection.
The Renaissance did not teach us to agree with everyone. It taught us that disagreement need not destroy our common humanity.
That is the lesson we must not forget.
A crowd may be angry, and its grievances may even be justified. But anger alone does not confer moral authority. Numbers do not replace evidence, noise does not establish truth, and intimidation does not amount to justice.
The greatness of a democratic society is demonstrated not by its ability to assemble a crowd but by its capacity to govern disagreement through reason and law.
The law must protect everyone
Nigeria’s constitutional framework is clear on this matter. Sections 34, 35, 39 and 40 of the 1999 Constitution protect human dignity, personal liberty, freedom of expression and peaceful assembly. These provisions must be read together, not selectively invoked to justify one person’s freedom at the expense of another’s.
The same principle finds expression in British law. Articles 10 and 11 of the European Convention on Human Rights, incorporated into domestic law through the Human Rights Act 1998, protect freedom of expression and peaceful assembly. They also recognise that these freedoms carry responsibilities and may be subject to lawful and proportionate restrictions necessary to protect public safety, prevent disorder and safeguard the rights of others.
This is the essence of constitutional democracy: rights are protected, but their exercise must respect the rights of fellow human beings.
I do not suggest that every forceful or vociferous demonstration is unlawful, any more than public officials should expect to be shielded from criticism, challenge or uncomfortable encounters. In a democracy, protest does not become unlawful simply because it is disruptive, inconvenient or unwelcome to those in authority.
The proper test is whether, viewed objectively and in its full context, the conduct crosses the threshold of illegality or warrants restriction under the law. It is essential that we preserve this distinction, for the right to protest must be protected, even as the law is upheld.
But where a demonstration crosses into threatening conduct, unlawful obstruction, harassment or intimidation, the law must be allowed to take its course.
An appeal to Chatham House and the British authorities
It is against this background that I respectfully appeal to the leadership of Chatham House and the appropriate authorities in the United Kingdom.
I appreciate that the reported confrontation took place outside the Institute’s premises. Nevertheless, the circumstances surrounding an incident involving a visiting speaker attending an engagement associated with Chatham House raise legitimate questions about the safety and security of those who participate in its programmes.
Chatham House has a responsibility, consistent with its position and capacity, to take an interest in what happened. I would therefore urge its management to establish the facts available to it, preserve any relevant security records or CCTV footage, review the circumstances of the incident and engage the appropriate authorities where necessary.
I also respectfully call upon the Metropolitan Police and the relevant British public safety and security authorities to look into the incident.
This is not a call for the suppression of peaceful protest, nor an attempt to criminalise political disagreement. It is a request that the reported conduct be independently examined, that those involved be heard, that available evidence be preserved and that any breach of British law be addressed appropriately.
If the conduct was entirely peaceful and lawful, that should be established. If, however, there was threatening behaviour, unlawful obstruction or any other criminal conduct, the appropriate legal consequences should follow.
The British tradition of justice is founded on an important principle: nobody should be above the law, and nobody should be beneath its protection.
That principle must apply irrespective of nationality, political affiliation, public office or personal conviction.
I would be particularly concerned if public officials, scholars, diplomats or other participants attending international engagements were made to feel that their safety could be compromised simply because their views or official responsibilities attract public disagreement.
Chatham House must remain a place where difficult conversations are possible, where unpopular opinions can be heard and where public officials can be challenged without fear of intimidation. This is not a demand for privilege. It is a demand for the minimum conditions necessary for meaningful intellectual engagement.
Nigeria must not confuse accountability with hostility
There is also a message here for us as Nigerians.
Our country is approaching another important electoral period. The credibility of our elections, the independence of our institutions and the confidence of citizens in the democratic process are matters of enormous national importance.
INEC must understand that public confidence cannot be commanded. It must be earned through transparency, fairness and professional conduct. Its leadership must be willing to listen, explain and correct genuine shortcomings.
But those who demand accountability must equally understand that the methods they employ matter.
We cannot build a democratic culture on intimidation. We cannot demand respect for constitutional institutions while disregarding the dignity of the individuals who serve them. And we cannot claim to be defending democracy if our actions undermine the very principles that give democracy its meaning.
I am equally reluctant to see this incident used to stigmatise Nigerians living in the United Kingdom. Our diaspora is diverse, accomplished and deeply committed to Nigeria’s progress. Its right to participate in national conversations must be protected. The conduct of a few individuals should never become a verdict on an entire community.
We should be able to disagree vigorously about our country’s future without losing respect for one another.
The civilisation we choose to defend
There is a thought from the great intellectual transition between the medieval world and the Renaissance that remains particularly relevant: civilisation is not measured simply by the institutions we build, but by the humanity we preserve in our dealings with one another.
The law is not merely a collection of rules. It is society’s solemn agreement that neither power nor anger, neither public office nor popular opinion, should be permitted to become an instrument of arbitrary domination.
That is why I believe this incident deserves more than passing commentary.
I urge Chatham House to take the matter seriously within its institutional responsibilities. I urge the British authorities to establish the facts and take whatever action the law requires. I urge the Nigerian electoral authorities to respond to legitimate concerns with openness and accountability. And I urge our compatriots, wherever they may be, to remember that the struggle for democracy must never become a struggle against human dignity.
We must defend the right to protest, but we must also defend the right to be free from intimidation. We must insist on accountability, but we must not abandon civility. Above all, we must never permit political passion to displace the rule of law.
There is a difference between a society in which people are free to disagree and one in which people are afraid to do so.
The former is democracy. The latter is the beginning of its decay.
The Renaissance taught Europe that reason must prevail over prejudice; the constitutional age taught us that power must submit to law. We should not, in our own time, allow the noise of the crowd to undo the wisdom of centuries.
Democracy deserves our passion, but it also demands our restraint. And the dignity of every human being must remain beyond the reach of the mob.



