NJC Sanctions Three Judges, Recommends 28 for Appointment, and Intervenes in Imo CJ Crisis
ABUJA — The National Judicial Council (NJC) has suspended three senior judges for one year without pay, issued sharp rebukes to several others, and recommended 28 candidates for immediate judicial appointment.
The far-reaching disciplinary and administrative actions were finalized during the council’s 112th meeting, presided over by the Chief Justice of Nigeria, Justice Kudirat Kekere-Ekun.
Three Judges Suspended for Abuse of Power
Following extensive investigations into nine petitions, the NJC approved the immediate one-year suspension without salary for three judicial officers, citing severe procedural infractions and violations of litigants’ fundamental rights.
In Nasarawa State, Justice Hannatu Kabir was suspended and barred from promotion for three years. An NJC investigation committee found she unlawfully detained a litigant for 58 days without instituting proper contempt proceedings or serving mandatory legal notices (Forms 48 and 49). The council ruled that the alleged contempt occurred outside her courtroom and could not lawfully be summarily punished.
In Rivers State, Justice Sobere received an identical one-year suspension and a three-year promotion freeze. Justice Biambo bypassed due process by issuing bench warrants and summarily imposing a ₦300,000 fine on litigants in a civil dispute without formal contempt proceedings.
In Jigawa State, Grand Kadi Mohammed Salihu was suspended for one year for exceeding his statutory authority. He was found to have improperly constituted a committee to review a valid judgement delivered by the FCT Upper Area Court, subsequently reassigning the matter to a Higher Sharia Court Judge to admit fresh evidence. The NJC directed the most senior Kadi in Jigawa State to oversee the office during the suspension.
Intervention in Imo Chief Judge Shortlist
The council also intervened in an administrative dispute in Imo State, ordering the state’s Judicial Service Commission (JSC) to immediately include the Acting Chief Judge, Justice Ijeoma Agugua, in its shortlist for the substantive Chief Judge position.
The directive followed a petition by Mr. Bob Kay Njemanze, who challenged the exclusion of Justice Agugua—the state’s most senior judge—from the initial list.
While acknowledging that the state JSC holds the constitutional mandate to advise the council, the NJC reasserted its ultimate authority to determine the suitability of candidates and ordered its secretariat to enforce her inclusion.
Malami Bail and High-Profile Cautions
The NJC issued strict warnings and placed six judicial officers on a six-month watchlist for various acts of judicial indiscretion. They are:
- Hon. Justice Bello Kawu (FCT High Court): Disciplined for granting interim bail to the former Attorney-General of the Federation, Mr. Abubakar Malami, SAN, despite knowing a subsisting remand order issued by a fellow judge of the same court was active.
- Hon. Justices Danjuma A. Oyigbenu and Isa Ebini Kana (Nasarawa State High Court): Issued warning letters for failing to deliver an appellate judgement within the constitutionally mandated 90 days, violating Section 294 of the 1999 Constitution.
- Hon. Justice Mohammed Zubairu (FCT High Court): Cautioned for “insubordination” after making orders on a case despite being formally notified that an appeal had already been entered at the Court of Appeal.
- Hon. Justice C. A. Ogbuagor (Enugu State High Court): Cautioned for “judicial impertinence” and denying a fair hearing by continuing proceedings in defiance of a pending appeal and stay of proceedings.
- Hon. Justice Kayode Agunloye (FCT High Court): Cautioned for creating “justifiable suspicion” by granting a fresh ex parte garnishee order for First Bank of Nigeria Plc while a stay of execution application was pending.
28 Judicial Nominees Approved
To bolster the bench across the federation, the NJC recommended 28 candidates for immediate appointment. The nominees include 24 High Court Judges, one Grand Kadi, one Kadi, and two Customary Court of Appeal Judges.
The approved candidates, expected to be sworn in by their respective state governors without delay, are:
Grand Kadi, Plateau State Sharia Court of Appeal:
- Hon. Kadi Zololo, Tijjani Jibrin
Kano State High Court: - Hassan, Nafisah Yusuf
- Ahmad, Halima Yahuza
- Bature, Abdullahi Abdulsalam
- Umar, Musa Ibrahim
Ebonyi State High Court:
- Amaga Dickson Edmund
Edo State High Court:
- Osawaru, Benson Osagie
- Omoruyi, Taiye Osayanmon
- Adamaigbo, Dorothy Ibhade
- Usiobaifo, Festus Osagie
- Oiwoh, Pius Idemudia
- Amune, Majebi Samuel
- Imuekemhe, Emike Jessica
Adamawa State High Court:
- Sa’ad, Aminu
- Musa, Ibrahim Ulenda
- Giwa, Sadiq
- Mijinyawa, Musa Bala
- Ibrahim, Japhet
- Bakari, Aliyu
- Ahmadu, Yakubu
Ogun State High Court:
- Oke, Olakulehin Luqman Abiola
- Obienu, Adebimpe Folusho
- Daudu, Fatimat Adeola
- Kadiri, Rafiat Bolanle
- Osho, Oludotun Olaniyi
Adamawa State Sharia Court of Appeal:
- Ishaku, Abubakar
Adamawa State Customary Court of Appeal: - Dimas, Elshama Gwama
- Pembi, David Benjamin
Petitions Dismissed or Maintained
Petitions against Hon. Justice B. M. Balarabe (Kaduna) and Hon. Justice Evelyn N. Anyadike were dismissed following their formal withdrawal. A petition against Hon. Justice Peter O. Ikujuni (Ondo) was struck out because it was leaked on social media in violation of the National Judicial Policy.
Conversely, the NJC refused to drop its probe into Hon. Justice G. N. Ugbala of the Ebonyi State High Court, ordering that the investigation must continue despite the petitioner’s withdrawal notice. Out of 35 other preliminary complaints reviewed, 24 were dismissed for lack of merit, and four were referred for deeper investigation.


